Detailed comparison of asphalt shingle roof vs slate roof

 Your roof serves a critical job in protecting everything under it, but it’s also an essential part of the curb appeal and decor of your home. Even though roofing has gotten more resilient and durable as technology has advanced, every homeowner will eventually need to repair their roof. When that time arrives, a homeowner has a vast range of roofing material options to choose from. Different types of roofing materials have distinct advantages and disadvantages that should be addressed during the decision process.

Asphalt shingles and slate tiles are two popular roofing materials nowadays. Though they both serve the same purpose of protecting the home from the elements, the similarities end there. When it comes to factors to consider when choosing a roofing material, slate tile and asphalt shingles are on opposing sides of the spectrum.

Cost Comparison

When determining the price of various roofing materials, there are two approaches to take. There’s the original installation cost, as well as long-term maintenance, care, and replacement expenditures. Asphalt shingles are the obvious choice for constructing a roof on a budget. Asphalt shingles are less expensive in the long run than slate tiles, and labour and installation costs are also lower. 3-tab asphalt shingles, on the other hand, typically only last around 20 years, while upgraded dimensional shingles can last up to 30 years. On the other hand, Slate roofing can endure up to 100 years which implies that one slate roof may outlast five 3-tab asphalt shingle roofs. While slate’s initial cost may be daunting, its long-term costs make it a cost-effective option.


Slate tiles are heavier than roofing shingles. Because slate tiles are heavier, a trained roofing contractor should evaluate your roof and ensure that the current roofing underlayment and frame can sustain the weight of the slate tiles. The underlayment and structure can be upgraded to more durable materials if necessary to support a slate roof. Failure to have your roof inspected may result in the top falling later due to the additional weight of slate roofing materials.


There are variations in the installation of roofing shingles and slate roofs. Most roofing projects can be done in a day


 or two, with the right roofing shingles installation crew. 

When it comes to slate roofing, it’s critical to choose a company specializing in this material. Compared to roofing shingles, the installation process is a little more involved and takes a little longer to complete.

The producers of the roofing materials have factory-educated our residential roofing installers and teams. As a result, they understand how to install your new slate or shingle roof properly.

Leave a Reply